~ CHAPTER 7 ~ KEY HABITATS ~ INVENTORIES ~ DEGRADATION ~
Edition 9 of October 2009 (Updated October 2010)

~ TABLE OF CONTENTS ~

(7-A) ~ Mangroves ~ [A1]~Global, [A2]~Africa, [A3]~Central America, [A4]~South America, [A5]~Oceania, [A6]~Asian Sub-continent, [A7]~Southeast Asia, [A8]~Singapore, ~
(7-B) ~
Coral Reefs ~ [B1]~Value, [B2]~Global, [B3]~Damage Mechanisms, [B4]~Africa, [B5]~Arabian Sea, [B6]~Australia, [B7]~Belize, [B8]~Caribbean, [B9]~Costa Rica, [B10]~Florida, [B11]~Southeast Asia, [B12]~Jamaica, [B13]~East Asia, [B14]~Philippines, [B15]~Singapore, [B16]~South America, [B17]~South Pacific, [B18]~Indian Ocean, [B19]~Oceania,
(7-C) ~
Estuaries and Coastal Wetlands ~ [C1]~Value, [C2]~Global, [C3]~US, [C4]~China, [C5]~Europe, [C6]~First World, [C7]~Southeast Asia, [C8]~Middle East, ~
(7-D) ~
Sargassum and Seagrass ~ [D1]~General, [D2]~Management, [D3]~Human Uses, [D4]~Role in Marine Ecosystems, ~
(7-E) ~
Key Habitats/ Inventories/Degradation ~ Freshwater Lakes and Rivers ~

~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi7

NOTE: The notation (su5) means that the data is used in the document analyzing the sustainability of the productivity of the world's food, fiber and water supply systems. (See elsewhere in this website.)

Comments:
Mangrove swamps, estuaries and coastal wetlands, because of their abundance of food, are nurseries for many species of fish. 2/3 of all commercially valuable fish species spend the first stage of their life in these waters (Ref. 15 of (93W1)), (80M1). 90% (by mass) of marine animals rely on coastal areas (mangrove swamps, estuaries and coastal wetlands) for spawning grounds (Ref. 16, Ch. 5 of (94B3)).

On the order of 2/3 of commercially valuable marine species depend on coastal habitats such as estuaries, wetlands and reefs. Most of the world's major estuaries are polluted by industry, agricultural- or urban runoff, or starved of nutrients by dams (Ref. 55 of (98W1)).

SECTION (7-A) ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ [A1]~Global, [A2]~Africa, [A3]~Central America, [A4]~South America, [A5]~Oceania, [A6]~Asian Sub-continent, [A7]~Southeast Asia, [A8]~Singapore, ~

Part [A1] ~ Mangroves ~ Global ~

Since the 1940s, parts of Asia have lost up to 90% of their mangrove forests (09P1).

Change in Mangrove Area by sub-region (p.253) (07A2)

Sub-region

1990
(km2)

2000
(km2)

Annual Change
(1990-2000) (%)

N.E. Asia

452

241

-8.0

South Asia

13,389

13,052

-0.2

S.E. Asia

52,740

44,726

-1.6

S. Pacific

6,320

5,520

-1.3

Australia/NZ

10,720

9,749

-0.9

Total Areas

83,621

73,288

-1.3

An intact mangrove area - important for building land in tropical areas - was estimated to be worth $1000/ ha in Thailand, vs. $200/ ha when cleared for aquaculture (05F1).

A fifth of the world's coral reefs, and a third of the world's mangrove forests, have been destroyed in recent decades (05F1).

A typical shrimp farm lasts for no more than 8 years before the chemicals and antibiotics that enter it as part of the shrimp-growing process make the ponds unusable. Shrimp farmers then move on. In the process, they cut more mangroves. The UN FAO estimates that, worldwide, 1% of the world's mangroves are destroyed each year. Several studies following the 2004 Asian tsunami found that villages protected by healthy mangrove forests experienced fewer casualties due to the fact that mangroves dissipate the power of the waves. India and Bangladesh have launched projects to restore mangrove forests as a means of creating storm buffers (08S1).

Today, over half the world's mangrove forests have been lost. Less than 16 million ha remain on coastlines that once were predominantly lined with thick stands of resilient mangroves. Offshore waters were once surrounded by protective and productive coral reefs and sea grass beds. These natural buffers protected the landward side, sheltering coastal communities and wildlife from the brunt of storms and waves. There is ample scientific evidence, for instance, that early shows that a 15 meter tsunami wave's destructive force is greatly dissipated as it passes through intact, healthy coastal zones containing coral, sea grass and mangroves. These "coastal greenbelts of protection" play a vital role in also reducing sedimentation and shoreline erosion, enhancing wild fisheries and providing marine life, medicines, fruit, honey, lumber, fuel wood, tannins and aesthetic beauty ("Loss Of Mangrove Forests Contributed To Greater Impact Of Tsunamis!", Mangrove Action Project, 1/4/05, PO Box 1854, Port Angeles, WA 98362-0279 (360-452-5866) mangroveap@olympus.net www.earthisland.org/map).

Mangroves ~ trees and shrubs that live in tropical tidal zones - line 25% of the world's tropical coastlines (Reference lost).

According to the US-based Earth Island Institute's Mangrove Action Project, mangrove forests once covered three-quarters of the coastlines of tropical and sub-tropical countries, but only half of that area remains intact today (The Mangrove News, 149th Edition, 1/16/05 Alfredo Quarto mangroveap@olympus.net).

Mangrove forests can reduce impact of tsunamis (The Mangrove News, 149th Edition, 1/16/05 Alfredo Quarto mangroveap@olympus.net).

Mangroves offer a double layer of protection against the surf: Low red mangroves anchor themselves in the mud flats along tidal estuaries. Their flexible branches and tangled roots absorb the sea's power. Behind them stand black mangroves as tall as trees (04B1).

It is estimated that over 50% of the world's mangroves have been destroyed and they continue to decline at an alarming rate. Shrimp aquaculture development has been a major cause of recent mangrove loss, and it has been estimated that shrimp aquaculture may have been responsible for as much as 38% of global loss of mangroves. Destruction of mangroves leaves coastal areas exposed to erosion, flooding and storm damage, alters natural drainage patterns, increases salt intrusion and removes critical habitats for many aquatic and terrestrial species, with serious implications for biodiversity, conservation and food security. Carnauba forests provide an important economic resource for rural communities, providing them with materials for the production of wax, straw and other saleable products. Shrimp farming is worth US$6.9 billion at the farm gate and US$50-60 billion at the point of retail. Shrimp are farmed in about 50 countries - 99% of farmed production is from developing countries. Leading shrimp producers in 2000 were Thailand, China, Indonesia, India, Vietnam, Ecuador, the Philippines, Bangladesh, Mexico and Brazil. Professor Ivan Valiela and colleagues at the Boston University Marine Program reported (2001) that conversion to shrimp aquaculture is responsible for 38% of total mangrove destruction, and that 'shrimp culture is, by a considerable margin, the greatest cause of mangrove loss. In at least 12 countries, wetland sites listed as having international importance under the Ramsar Convention have been damaged or destroyed (Alfredo Quarto <mangroveap@olympus.net> The Mangrove Action Project News, 145th Edition, Part 1 of 3 9/18/04, http://www.earthisland.org/map/map.html).

Restoring mangroves cost US$10,000 to $100,000/ km2. Yet loggers and shrimp aquaculture prospectors can lease mangrove forests for a few hundred $/ km2 (00M1). The total ecological value of mangroves in terms of food production, storm protection and waste treatment has been estimated at about US$1,000,000/ km2/ year (00M1). Comments: This is the cost of providing the same services by other means.

Mangrove forest loss in selected countries since pre-agricultural times (93W3) (la) (All losses and inventories are in km2)

Indonesia

21220

(45% of 47,116)

Nigeria

12320

(50% of 24,640)

Malaysia

7384

(32% of 23,075)

Cameroon

4908

(40% of 12,270)

Sierra Leone

3434

(50% of 6,868)

Guinea-Bissau

3183

(70% of 4,547)

Bangladesh

2940

(73% of 4,027)

Mozambique

2787

(60% of 4,645)

Tanzania

2142

(60% of 3,570)

Philippines

785

(80% of 981)

Total

61103

(46% of*131,739)

* (of countries on this list)
Source: WRI, UNEP 1990, Australian Institute of Marine Science (1992).

Mangrove Areas in Selected Countries ((00W3), p. 74) (la) Data of Burke et al [PAGE]~2000, Areas are in km2

Country

Current
Extent

Loss

Period

Angola

1100

50%

Original-1980s

Cote d'Ivoire

640

60

Original-1980s

Gabon

1150

50

Original-1980s

Guinea-Bissau

3150

70

Original-1980s

Kenya

610

4

1971-1988

Tanzania

2120

60

Original-1980s

Costa Rica

413

-6

1983-1990

El Salvador

415

8

1983-1990

Guatemala

161

31

1960s-90s

Jamaica

106

30

Original-1990s

Mexico

5315

65

1970s-90s

Panama

1581

67

1983-1990

Peru

51

25

1982-1992

Brunei

200

20

Original-1986

Indonesia

24237

55

Original-1980s

Malaysia

2327

74

Original-1992-93

Myanmar

4219

75

Original-1992-93

Pakistan

1540

78

Original-1980s

Philippines

1490

67

1918-1980s

Thailand

1946

84

Original-1993

Vietnam

2625

37

Original-1993

Papua New Guinea

4627

8

Original-1992-93

Overall it is estimated that close to 50% of the world's mangrove forests have been destroyed (95K1).

More than 50% of the world's mangroves have been lost in recent decades (00M1).

One km2 of mangrove forest can sustainably produce 38 tonnes of fish per year, and provide nursery grounds for an added 48 tonnes of fish and shrimp that mature elsewhere each year. The high density, intensive shrimp ponds that are replacing mangroves produce 100-300 tonnes/ km2/ year for about 5 years, at which point the ponds must be abandoned as a result of being abandoned because they are so choked with waste that they cannot support life of any kind (Ref. 30 of (99M1)). Comments: Data seems to be lacking on the fallow period required to restore these ponds. Also the economic analysis needs estimates of the value of the storm-protection and water-regulation benefits provided by mangroves.

Loss of mangrove forest results in increased sediment transport onto downstream coral reefs (Ref. 37 of Ref. (00N1)).

Globally, coastal mangroves now cover 200,000 km2 (97S1). (la)

Some 80-90% of the commercial seafood species that inhabit the world's tropical oceans spend some part of their lives in coastal mangroves (94H2).

Mangroves line 8% of the world's coastlines (Burke et al [PAGE]~2000) and about 25% of tropical coastlines, covering a surface area of 181,000 km2 (97S2). (la)

Some 112 of the world's countries and territories have mangroves within their border (97S2).

Shrimp are often produced by clearing coastal mangrove forests that protect coastlines and serve as nurseries for local fish. Mangrove destruction can cause a decline of local fisheries that will actually exceed the gains from shrimp production, leading to a net protein loss (00W2).

About 50% of the world's mangrove swamps and salt marshes have been destroyed for farmland, fishponds or industrial developments (Ref. 55 of Ref. (98W1)).

Well over 50% of the original areas of mangroves in tropical countries have been lost (Ref. 16, Chapter 5 of (94B3)). Because of the loss of half the world's mangrove forests, the world's coastal fishers may have lost 4.7 million tons of fish/ year, including 1.5 million tons/ year of shrimp (Ref. 48 of (94W2)). Mangrove forests are being cut for charcoal, pulp, clearance for salt making, and aquaculture ponds.

Shrimp farmers (aquaculture) clear-cut mangroves and other coastal ecosystems, then bulldoze shallow pools. Drugs can control diseases in these pools for about 7 years, then the pools must be abandoned and the process repeated further along the coast. The wasteland left behind is soil-deficient and too polluted to replant (97M1). Comments: The physical elimination of soil by bulldozing suggests that the time required for recovery of these ponds to agricultural usefulness must be on the order of centuries, though the recovery for aquacultural usefulness may be less.

Part [A2] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ Africa ~

[A2a] ~ Mangroves ~ Africa ~ Tanzania ~

Tanzania has banned the destruction of its remaining 810 km2 of mangroves (89L1). (la)

There are plans to establish a 100 km2 shrimp farm in the Rufiji Delta of Tanzania, an area containing 530 km2 of mangrove forests (01M2).

[A2b] ~ Mangroves ~ Africa ~ Niger Delta ~

The Niger Delta contains the third-largest contiguous mangrove forest in the world (99M6).

Over 35,000 km2 of mangrove forests have been lost thus far in the Niger Delta (99M6).

Part [A3] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ Central America ~

[A3a] ~ Mangroves ~ Central America ~ Dominican Republic

Mangroves are largely gone in the Dominican Republic (93W2).

[A3b] ~ Mangroves ~ Central America ~ Haiti ~

Mangroves are largely gone (93W2).

[A3c] ~ Mangroves ~ Central America ~ Jamaica ~

Mangroves are largely gone in Jamaica (93W2).

[A3d] ~ Mangroves ~ Central America ~ Panama ~

Panama lost 67% of its mangroves during the 1980s (93D1).

[A3e] ~ Mangroves ~ Antigua (Caribbean island) ~

A third of the island's remaining mangroves were destroyed to make way for a resort development before local people succeeded in stopping the bulldozers (Anjali Acharya, Worldwatch, 8(6) (1995)).

Part [A4] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ South America ~

[A4a] ~ Mangroves ~ South America ~ Ecuador ~

Ecuador's 5-year prohibition against mangrove cutting started in 1994. It has now been extended indefinitely. Some 32% of the original mangrove forest still stands (99M6).

The Cayapas-Mataje Mangrove Reserve in Ecuador contains 530 km2 on the border with Colombia. Ecuador's other mangrove area is Muisne where 250 km2 of mangroves have been reduced to 6 km2 (00M1). (la)

Some 33% of Ecuador's mangroves have been converted to ponds for shrimp fishing (89L1). Shrimp farming has reduced mangrove forests by at least 25% (94H2). Ecuador has lost 800 km2 of mangrove forests and salt flats to shrimp ponds over the past 23 years (94W1). About 20% of Ecuador's mangrove forests were converted to shrimp farms during 1979-1991 (EDF Letter, 27(1) (1996) p. 7). (la)

[A4b] ~ Mangroves ~ South America ~ Brazil ~

New legislation in Brazil bans farming in mangrove swamp areas and stipulates that shrimp farmers must obtain environmental licenses to operate ("Shrimp farming banned in mangroves" (Brazil) www.FIS.com (10/25/02)).

Today there are about 50 km2 of shrimp farms in Brazil, some built directly in mangrove areas (01M2). Expansion to 300 km2 in 3 years is planned (01M2).

The Brazilian government proposes to allow 10% of Brazil's mangroves to be cut for shrimp-pond development (01M2).

Brazil contains the second-largest mangrove area in the world. Possibly over 10,000 km2 of mangrove forests are found along Brazil's coastline (01M2). (la)

[A4c] ~ Mangroves ~ South America ~ Colombia ~

Colombia has 3659 km2 of mangroves, of which 80% extend along the Pacific Coast (99M6). (la)

Part [A5] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ Oceania ~

[A5a] ~ Mangroves ~ Oceania ~ Fiji

About $300 million is being spent to clear mangroves on the island of Denarau to build golf courses, hotels and a marina (Anjali Acharya, Worldwatch, 8(6) (1995)).

Part [A6] ~ Mangroves ~ Asian Sub-Continent ~

The Indus delta region contains the world's fifth-largest mangrove forest. This forest is deteriorating markedly from rising salinity, decline of nutrients, erosion and land subsidence. (R. Leichenko, James L. Wescoat Jr., "Environmental Impacts of Climate Change and Water Development in the Indus Delta Region", Water Resources Development, 9(3) (1993)) (su5)

The protective reefs, sand dunes and mangroves that look out to the Indian Ocean in a broad arc from Sri Lanka to Bangladesh and Indonesia have been dynamited and bulldozed (04B1).

[A6a] ~ Mangroves ~ Asian Sub-Continent ~ India

When the tsunami struck India's southern state of Tamil Nadu on 12/26/04 areas in Pichavaram and Muthupet with dense mangroves suffered fewer human casualties and less damage to property compared to areas without mangroves. In October 1999, mangrove forests reduced the impact of a 'super-cyclone' that struck Orissa on India's east coast, killing at least 10,000 people and making 7.5 million homeless. Those human settlements located behind healthy mangrove stands suffered little, if any, losses ("Loss Of Mangrove Forests Contributed To Greater Impact Of Tsunamis", Mangrove Action Project, 1/4/05, PO Box 1854, Port Angeles, WA 98362-0279 (360-452-5866) mangroveap@olympus.net www.earthisland.org/map).

India laid waste to as much as 50% of its mangroves during 1963-1977 (04B1).

The Indus delta region contains the world's fifth-largest mangrove forest. This forest is deteriorating markedly from rising salinity, decline of nutrients, erosion and land subsidence (93L1).

During 1963-1977, almost 50% of India's mangroves were cut down (89L1).

India has lost at least 75% of its mangroves (Ref. 9 of (92R1)).

In the Bay of Bengal, 90% of the commercial fish depend on healthy mangroves for survival (98M1). India's coastal mangroves cover 15% of their original coverage (97S1).

In one coastal village in India, fishers reported a 10-fold drop in wild fish harvest one year after shrimp farms were built. In an area in Bangladesh, fishers experienced an 80% decline in wild catches after mangroves were cut down and replaced by shrimp farms that altered fresh- and saltwater flows (Ref. 116 of (98M7)).

During 1986-1998, 120 km2 of mangroves were replanted in the Indus Delta (Ref. 130 of (99M1)).

[A6b] ~ Mangroves ~ Asian Sub-Continent ~ Pakistan ~

Pakistan has lost at least 75% of its mangroves (Ref. 9 of (92R1)).

[A6c] ~ Mangroves ~ Asian Sub-Continent ~ Bangladesh ~

The Sundarbans Reserve Forest of Bangladesh covers 6017 km2 of mangrove forests, wildlife sanctuaries, sandbars, rivers and canals (00M1).

Part [A7] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ Southeast Asia ~

In the Philippines, 2,500 km2 of mangrove (more than half the area that existed 80 years ago) has been destroyed. Some 60% of this loss is attributed to coastal culture of prawns and milkfish (03U2).

In Myanmar's (Burma's?) Irrawaddy Delta, the region ravaged by the cyclone of 5/2/08 vast swaths of mangroves had been cleared over the decades to make way for rice fields and shrimp farms and to provide wood for fuel. Mangrove forests used to serve as a buffer between the rising tide, big waves and storms and the residential area. Mangroves, with dense network of trees and shrubs that live in tropical tidal zones, line 25% of the world's tropical coastlines. But in Asia they have been uprooted to create farmland, aquaculture farms and urban developments. About 83% of the mangroves in the Irrawaddy Delta were destroyed during the period 1924-1999 (08S1).

Destruction of mangroves was begun by British colonial authorities that encouraged rice cultivation in the delta that was once known as the "rice bowl" of the world. In other parts of Asia, the greater spoiler of coastline mangroves is shrimp farms. This is because Thailand, Indonesia and India have become some of the world's biggest shrimp exporters. Shrimp farms demand brackish waters and flat land. Both are common where mangroves commonly grow (08S1).

People in the city of Rangoon cannot afford propane or gas, so mangroves are harvested for firewood (08S1).

Mangroves have also been converted to agricultural lands. However this causes residents to move closer to the sea and to build homes in areas with high risks of destruction due to the actions of the sea. Many villages in Myanmar are in rice-growing areas that are below sea level (08S1).

The protective reefs, sand dunes and mangroves that look out to the Indian Ocean in a broad arc from Sri Lanka to Bangladesh and Indonesia have been dynamited and bulldozed (04B1).

Thousands of km2 of mangroves and coastal wetlands have been transformed into milkfish and shrimp ponds in Southeast Asia (00N1). In Southeast Asia, mangrove-dependent species account for roughly 1/3 of wild fish landings excluding trash fish. A positive relationship between finfish and shrimp landings and mangrove area has been documented in Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines (Refs. 32-34 of Ref.(00N1)). Mangroves are also linked closely to habitat conditions of coral reefs and seagrass beds (Refs. 35 and 36 of Ref. (00N1)).

[A7a] ~ Mangroves ~ Southeast Asia ~ Indonesia ~

In Indonesia, Java has lost 70% of its mangrove area, Sulawesi 49%, Sumatra 36%. Globally the rate of decline in mangrove forest cover is 2-8%/ year, said the paper (The Mangrove News, 149th Edition, 1/16/05 Alfredo Quarto mangroveap@olympus.net).

In Kalimantan Province of Indonesia, 95% of all mangroves are to be cleared for pulpwood (Ref. 9 of (92R1)).

In Indonesia's Aceh province, devastated by the tsunami of 12/26/04, mangroves are being harvested as timber for sale to Malaysia and Singapore (04B1).

[A7b] ~ Mangroves ~ Southeast Asia ~ Philippines ~

Aquaculture expansion in the Philippines is expected to eliminate all mangroves there in 10 years (89L1).

Mangroves in the Philippines are over 80% gone (Ref. 25 of (93W2)).

[A7c] ~ Mangroves ~ Southeast Asia ~ Thailand ~

Shrimp farming alone caused a loss of 65,000 hectares of mangroves in Thailand, according to a 2002 paper by V. P. Upadhyay and colleagues in the journal Current Science (The Mangrove News, 149th Edition, 1/16/05 Alfredo Quarto mangroveap@olympus.net).

Much of the estimated 84% of the original mangroves lost to Thailand were lost since 1975 (97M2) ((97S2), p. 66).

During 1975-1993, Thailand's mangrove area was almost halved (statement by Edward Barbier, editor of a recent book on Asia's disappearing mangrove systems.) (04B1).

In Thailand, half the mangrove forests were lost in the 1980s, in large part due to shrimp farm development. The ponds yielded 120,000 tons of farmed shrimp annually, but they precipitated the loss of 800,000 tons of wild fish harvest (Ref. 116 of (98M7)).

Shrimp farming in Thailand has reduced mangrove forests by at least 25% (94H2).

Thailand has lost at least 75% of its mangroves (Ref. 9 of (92R1)).

Thailand's coastal mangroves cover 13% of their original coverage (97S1).

[A7d] ~ Mangroves ~ Southeast Asia ~ Vietnam ~

Over 80% of Vietnam's mangrove forests have been lost ("World Bank Says Vietnam's Environment is Rapidly Deteriorating", Associated Press (9/18/02)).

Part [A8] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Mangroves ~ Singapore ~

Almost all of Singapore's mangroves have been removed (Ref. 25 of (94W1)).

Go to Top of this Chapter-Key Habitats - Inventories, Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi7

SECTION (7-B) ~ CORAL REEFS ~ [B1]~Values, [B2]~Global, [B3]~Damage Mechanisms, [B4]~Africa, [B5]~Arabian Sea, [B6]~Australia, [B7]~Belize, [B8]~Caribbean, [B9]~Costa Rica, [B10]~Florida, [B11]~Indonesia, [B12]~Jamaica, [B13]~East Asia, [14]~Philippines, [15]~Singapore, [16]~South America, [17]~South Pacific, [18]~Indian Ocean, [19]~Oceania, ~

Part [B1] ~ Coral Reefs ~ Values ~

Hundreds of millions of people worldwide - by some estimates, 1 billion across Asia alone - depend on coral reefs for their food and their livelihoods. (Data of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN data of 2008))

Reefs harbor at least 25% of all marine life. About 10% of the world's fisheries come from reefs, and much of this feeds protein-starved people in under-developed countries (
01R2).

Officials in the Maldives (off the southwest coast of India) said extensive (coral) reefs (500 miles in length according to James Hookway, Wall Street Journal (12/30/04), p. A7) smothered the tsunami of 12/26/04 (04B1).

While covering less than 1% of the Earth's surface, coral reefs provide the planet with $375 billion in economic benefits globally (yearly??) (04H1).

Coral reefs are estimated to be worth $375 billion/ year by providing fish, medicines, tourism revenues and coastal protection for more than 100 countries (World Resources Institute, "Reefs at Risk: A Map-based Indicator of Threats to the World's Coral Reefs," Washington DC 1998).

(general) According to one estimate, coral reefs provide goods and services worth about $375 billion/ year - a staggering figure for an ecosystem that covers less than 1% of the earth's surface (02M2). Comments: Somewhere else is a statement that coral reefs cover under 0.1% of the world's oceans.

(habitat) Coral reefs provide habitat for over one million species of plants and animals (97H3).

(habitat) Coral reefs anchor many marine ecosystems; their loss could mean extinction for thousands of species of fish and other marine life (00V1).

(Habitat) Coral reefs provide shelter, breeding areas, nurseries and food for shellfish, invertebrates and fish; and form an important link in cycling nutrients from the land to the open ocean (96H1).

(food) Coral reefs are the main source of animal protein for over one billion poor people in Asia (97H3).

(food) In developing countries, coral reefs contribute about one-quarter of the total fish catch, providing food to an estimated one billion people in Asia alone (02M2).

(food) About 500 million people rely on (coral) reefs for food and income (00V1).

(food) Fisheries capture from reefs contribute 10% of the fish for human consumption globally, and a far larger fraction in developing nations (Ref. 37 of Ref. (00N1)).

(Coastline protection) Coral reefs protect coastlines from storm damage and beach erosion (96H1).

(Food) (Coral) Reefs provide food and breeding grounds for 10% of all fish caught for human consumption (95W1). Nearly a third of the world's fish live in coral reefs (96H1).

(food) In 1986, Apo Island (in Mindanao Sea, off southern coast of Negros in Philippines) established 8% of its coral reef as a reserve, where no activities would be permitted, except scuba diving and snorkeling. By 1988 stocks of edible fish and shellfish had recovered to such an extent that the people could catch all the fish they needed around their island again (97H3).

Part [B2] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Global ~

By 2004, an estimated 20% of the world's coral reefs had been destroyed (up from 11% in 2000), an additional 24% of the world's coral reefs were close to collapsing, and another 26% were under long-term threat of collapse. (NOAA data of around 2008)

Some 50% of the Caribbean's corals are already dead, largely because of climate change, over-fishing and pollution (NOAA data of around 2008).  

At least 19% of the world's coral reefs are gone, including some 50% of those in the Caribbean.
An additional 15% of the world's coral reefs could be dead within 20 years (
Data of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration NOAA).

Status of coral reefs by sub-region in 2004 (p.253) (from a chart) (Areas are in thousands of km2) (07A2)

Col. 3 - Area threatened+ critical+ destroyed
Col. 4 - Area critical+ destroyed
Col. 5 - Area destroyed

Region

Total

Col. 3

Col. 4

Col. 5

N.E. Asia

5

2.5

1.5

0.4

South Asia

19

16

10

8.~

S.E. Asia

91

87

60

35.~

South Pacific

27

17

6

0.5

Australia/ N.Z.

62

12

3

1.~

Totals

204

135

81

45.~

Only 5% of the world's coral reefs can still be considered pristine. About 25% of these coral reefs have been lost (08G1).

In less than 50 years, the world's oceans may be too acidic for coral reefs to grow. Emissions of CO2 are boosting acidity so much that seawater covering 98% of all coral reefs may be too acidic by 2050 for some coral to live, while others that may survive would be unable to build reefs. About one-third of CO2 put into the atmosphere is absorbed by the world's oceans. CO2 produces carbonic acid that reduces concentrations of carbonate ions that are critical to reef building. The reefs of Australia and the Caribbean are at the greatest risk because they already have lower carbonate ion concentrations and therefore would reach critical levels sooner. (Ove Hoegh-Guldberg et al, Science (12/13/07).)

Coral produce $375 billion/ year in economic value worldwide (from an analysis by the Nature Conservancy) (Jim Loney, "Acid seas huge threat to coral reefs-study," Reuters (12/13/07)).

A study of 322 coral reef sites across 13 countries between 1999 and 2001 (authored by Camilo Mora of Dalhousie University of Halifax Canada and reported in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B) found that the number of people in close proximity to the reefs was the main factor governing the rates of decline in coral reefs (James Randerson, "Human activity blamed for decline of coral reefs," The Guardian, (1/9/08).

The coral reefs in 55% of the 49 island countries reviewed in a report published in Current Biology in April of 2007 were being exploited unsustainably. Fish landings are currently 64% higher than can be sustained. (See Science Daily of 4/9/07.) (The research was done at the University of East Anglia, the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science [CEFAS]~and Simon Fraser University in Canada.)

Some 58% of the world's coral reefs are imperiled by humans (UN report on global ecosystems to be released in 9/2000. The $4 million study is the outcome of a program called Pilot Analysis of Global Ecosystems (PAGE)).

Up to 70% of the world's shallow coral reefs could be gone in the next few decades (01R2).

About 25% of the world's (coral) reefs have already been lost, and those remaining are under stress from pollution, sedimentation, destructive fishing practices and global climate change (01R2).

About 30% of the world's coral reefs are healthy, down from 41% 2 years ago, according to a study released 12/6/04 by 240 scientists in 96 countries (04H1). (The study's lead author, Clive Wilkinson, is coordinator of the Global Reef Monitoring Network.)

Status of Coral Reefs, by Region, in the mid-1990s: (Reef areas in km2) (Col. 3 is Share of Total at High or Medium Risk, expressed in %) (Source: World Resources Institute, "Reefs at Risk: A Map-based Indicator of Threats to the World's Coral Reefs," Washington DC 1998).

Region

Area

At Risk

Middle East

20,000

61

Caribbean

20,000

61

Atlantic

3,100

87

Indian Ocean

36,100

54

Southeast Asia

68,100

82

Pacific

108,000

41

Global

255,300

58

Between 1992 and 2000, the share of severely damaged reefs. worldwide, expanded from 10 to 27% (Clive Wilkinson, "Status of Coral Reefs of the World: 2000 (Townsville Australia: Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network, 2000, p.1).

A global map of coral reefs is in Ref. (00W3), p. 75.

Callum M. Roberts et al, Science (2/15/02) p.1280 Coral Reef Areas of the World with the richest number of species - but which also face the most severe threats The article puts 18 places on the list of areas with the highest number of species. The 10 most threatened of these are listed below, ranked according to degree of threat.
Philippines
Gulf of Guinea Islands off West Africa
Sunda Islands in Indonesia
Southern Mascarene Islands near Madagascar
Eastern South Africa
Northern Indian Ocean near Sri Lanka
Southern Japan, Taiwan and southern China
Cape Verde Islands off West Africa
Western Caribbean, from Cozumel Mexico to Columbia
Red Sea and Gulf of Aden

The world's (coral) reefs occupy 294,533 km2 corresponding to 0.1% of the total surface area of the world's oceans (01U4). (la)

Worldwide, an estimated 255,000 km2 of shallow coral reefs exist, with more than 90% in the Indo-Pacific region (97S3). (la)

Some 27% of the world's coral reefs have been lost. Some 14% will suffer destruction in the next 10-20 years. In 2002, more than 400 of the world's (coral) reefs suffered bleaching. Reefs in eastern Africa and the Indian Ocean continue to degrade because of sediment and nutrient runoff and over-exploitation of reef resources. About 60% of the Great Barrier Reef (Australia) was bleached in 2002. Some inshore reefs suffer up to 90% coral death ("Coral Reefs Start Slow Recovery", BBC News (12/2002)).

The three countries with the largest reefs are Indonesia 52,835 km2, Australia 50,722 km2, and the Philippines 25,899 km2 (01U4). (la)

A 265-page report, "The State of Coral Reef Ecosystems of the United States and Pacific Freely Associated States," http://ens-news.com/ens/sep2002/2002-09-30-06.asp identifies the pressures that pose increasing risks to the nation's estimated 7,607 square miles (19,700 km2) of coral reefs, particularly in hot spots located near population centers. The report also assesses the health of reef resources, ranks threats in 13 geographic areas, and details ongoing efforts to mitigate damage to coral reefs.

Trawling has been around 100 years, since the advent of powerboats. However, corals at least 800 years old are being destroyed as 14.8 million km2/ year are trawled worldwide (00L1).

Some 58% of the world's coral reefs are imperiled by humans. (UN report on global ecosystems to be released in September, 2000.) The $4 million study is the outcome of a program called Pilot Analysis of Global Ecosystems (PAGE))

A report from the Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network estimates that 25% of the world's reefs are already gone or severely damaged, and that another third are degraded and threatened (02M2).

According to a detailed survey from the World Conservation Monitoring Center of the UN Environment Program coral reefs are both smaller and dying faster than previously thought. They are rapidly being degraded by human activities. A large fraction of the world's (coral) reefs are threatened: Thailand and the Philippines (97%), Indonesia (82%), Malaysia (91%), Papua New Guinea (46%), and Australia (32%) (01U4). (la)

Coral reefs have been on earth for 500 million years (Ref. 13 of (93W2)). Most coral reefs are 5,000-10,000 years old (96H1). Coral reefs occupy 0.17% of the Earth's surface, but are home to 25% of all marine fish species (Ref. 6 of (93W2)). 109 countries have shores lined with reefs. The total length of these reefs exceeds 100,000 km (93W2). Roughly 414,000 km2 of coral reefs are scattered throughout the world's tropical and sub-tropical seas (96H1). (la)

The "first atlas" of the world's coral reefs has found that they cover a much smaller area of the globe than previously thought says. Scientists say reefs are being damaged faster than researchers can collect data about them and their ecosystems and estimate that more than half the reefs are under threat from human activities. The UN World Conservation Monitoring Center survey found that scientists have "no idea how much" of the world's coral reefs have already been lost (BBC News (9/11/01)).

Scientists and experts from around the world meeting at the first International Symposium on "deep- sea, cold-water coral biology, ecology and conservation" have warned that "more than half of the world's deep-sea coral reefs have been destroyed". Unlike the well know shallow water, tropical corals, deep-sea corals grow in a cold, sunless environment where they filter nutrients "to collect most of their food." Modern fishing practices, such as bottom trawling and dragging, are having a devastating impact on these marine ecosystems (ENN 8/10/2000).

About 10% of the world's coral reefs are degraded beyond recognition, and 30% in critical condition (97H3).

(pollution) Approximately 5-10% of the world's coral reefs have been essentially destroyed by pollution and direct destruction, and another 30% are threatened (Ref. 55 of (98W1)).

Coral reefs are among the largest and oldest living communities of plants and animals on earth, having evolved between 200-450 million years ago (97H3). Today, most established coral reefs are 5,000-10,000 years old; many of them forming thin veneers over older, much thicker reef structures. Most of the reef colony is actually dead. Only the upper layer is covered by a thin changeable 'skin' of living coral (97H3).

Scientists estimate 600,000 km2 of coral reefs are scattered throughout the world's tropical and sub-tropical seas (97H3). (la)

Only reefs in remote regions of the world are generally healthy (93W2).

Coral grow from just below sea level down to 30 meters, at which point the light (needed to power the algae (zooxanthellae) which supply coral with food and oxygen) becomes insufficient (93W2).

A map of the world's coral reefs is shown in Ref. (93W2). This map categorizes reefs as "critical" (loss in 10-20 years), "threatened" (loss in 20-40 years) or "stable".

The loss of 5-10% of the world's coral reefs translates to a loss of fish on the order of 250,000-500,000 tons/ year (Ref. 49 of (94W2)).

Destruction of coral reefs has reduced potential global fish catches by $80 million/ year (89L1). Reefs off at least 80 countries are threatened by over-fishing (Ref. 36 of (93W2)). The total catch from reefs is estimated at 4-8 million tons/ year - about 10% of the fish caught for use as human food (93W2).

Coral reefs account for 20-25% of fish caught by developing countries (Ref. 11 of (93W2)). 4 million small-scale fishers - 1/3 of all subsistence fishers - obtain their catch from coral reefs (Ref. 12 of (93W2)).

Pacific islanders obtain up to 90% of their animal protein from reef fish (Ref. 10 of (93W2)).

Southeast Asian coral reefs can support 5-15 times the number of fish found in the entire North Atlantic (96H1).

Some 70-90% of all fish caught by coastal fishermen in tropical Asia are reef-dependent at one time or another in their life (96H1).

The status and decline of the world's coastal reefs are documented in Ref. (94W2).

Clive Wilkinson, a coral reef expert working at the Australian Institute of Marine Science in Townsville insists that if nothing is done in time to conserve and manage coral reefs, the world may well lose 70% of them within 40 years (97H3).

About 10% of the world's reefs are dead or damaged beyond the capacity to recover, according to US Government reports (95W1). At the current rate of loss, an added 30% will disappear in the next 2 decades (95W1).

People have, directly or indirectly, caused the death of 5-10% of the world's living (coral) reefs, and at current rates, will destroy another 60% in the next 20-40 years (Ref. 19 of (93W2)).

A study from the World Conservation Union and UNEP in the mid-1980s (Ref. 4 of (93W2)) found that people had damaged or destroyed significant amounts of reef off the coasts of 93 countries (93W2).

If trends continue, within 4 decades only 155,000 km2 of the world's 600,000 km2 of coral reefs will be left intact and functioning (Reference citation apparently lost.) (la)

About 10% of the world's (coral) reefs have been degraded "beyond recognition." About 30% are in critical condition and will be lost completely in 10-20 years if trends continue; another 30% are threatened, and will be lost within 20-40 years if trends continue (96H1).

Some 93% of the 109 countries with significant coral reefs were damaging them (96H1).

Global and Regional Reef Areas in 1997 ((00W3), p. 75) (la) Areas are in units of 1000 km2.

Region

Area

World

255 (100.%)

Indo-Pacific

233 (91.4%)

Western Pacific*

105 (41.2%)

Eastern Pacific

3 ( 1.2%)

Red Sea

17 ( 6.7%)

Arabian Gulf

3 ( 1.2%)

Indian Ocean

36 (14.1%)

Southeast Asia

68 (26.7%)

Atlantic

22 ( 8,6%)

Wider Caribbean

21 ( 8.2%)

West Africa

1 ( 0.4%)

(* including Hawaii)

Location of the World's Reefs (93W2)

Southeast Asia

30%

Caribbean

9%

Pacific Ocean

25%

Atlantic Ocean

6%

Indian Ocean

24%

Middle East

6%

Areas with Tracts of Particularly Devastated Reefs (93W2)

Japan

Taiwan

Philippines

Indonesia

Singapore

Cuba

Sri Lanka

Mozambique

Florida

Madagascar

India

Kenya

Tanzania

Dominican Rep.

.

Haiti

Jamaica

Trinidad

Tobago

.

Part [B3] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Damage Mechanisms ~

Although the US and many other countries forbid using cyanide and explosives to stun fish, these methods are still widely practiced in the South Pacific and Southeast Asia (01R2). Comments: This practice is apparently carried out mainly in reef areas.

Sources of Information on Coral Reef Degradation (02M2):
Barber, C. V., and V. R. Pratt, "Sullied seas: Strategies for combating cyanide fishing in Southeast Asia and beyond", World Resources Institute, Washington, DC (1997).
Bryant, D., L. Burke, J. McManus, and M. Spalding, "Reefs at risk: A map-based indicator of threats to the world's coral reefs", World Resources Institute, Washington, DC (1998).
Clark, A. M., and D. Gulko, "Hawaii's state of the reefs report, 1998". Department of Land and Natural Resources, Honolulu, Hawaii.
Dayton, P., Reversal of the burden of proof in fisheries management. Science 279: (1999) pp.821-822.
Green, E., and F. Shirley, "The global trade in coral", WCMC Biodiversity Series No.9. World Conservation Monitoring Centre. World Conservation Press, Cambridge, UK (1999).
Hodgson, G., A global assessment of human effects on coral reefs. Marine Pollution Bulletin. 38(5): (1999) pp. 345-55.
Roberts, C., "Effects of fishing on the ecosystem structure of coral reefs", Conservation Biology 9(5) (1995) pp. 989-92.
Wilkinson, C. (editor), Status of the coral reefs of the world: 2000. Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network and Australian Institute of Marine Science, Cape Ferguson and Dampier, Australia. (http://www.aims.gov.au/scr2000).

(general) Coral reefs are in serious trouble worldwide from a powerful combination of stresses that are threatening their survival, including: overexploitation of resources for subsistence and commercial fishing; destructive fishing practices that degrade and destroy the habitat itself; increasing coastal populations, which are expected to double in the next 50 years; poor land use practices and runoff of pollutants, sediments and nutrients; disease outbreaks, which may be associated with poor water quality and pollutants; coral bleaching, associated with increasing seawater temperatures and global change; and removal of coastal mangrove forests (02M2).

(general) Global warming damages the coral by bleaching, a process in which the reefs heat up and expel the microscopic plants that give them their color (00V1).

(general) Some 58% of the world's coral reefs are potentially threatened by destructive fishing practices, tourist pressures and pollution ((98B3), p. 6).

(general) Many coral reefs around the world are increasingly threatened, principally from over-fishing, excessive inputs of sediments and nutrients from human activity (pollution, deforestation, reef-mining, dredging) (94H4). Reefs are being excavated for use in cement, killed off by industrial pollutants, smothered by sediment eroded from cleared land, and choked by untreated sewage. Coral reefs are susceptible to these disturbances because they depend on sunlight (96H1).

(fishing practices) Various explosives, such as dynamite and homemade bombs, are also used to kill fish for easy collection, but at an enormous cost to the reef that is reduced to rubble. In Komodo National Park in Indonesia, about half of the coral reefs have been destroyed through the use of explosives, forming beds of coral rubble that can extend several football fields in length. While the use of explosives to collect dead fish is usually for domestic trade, some of the fish that are only stunned will enter the international trade stream (02M2).

(fishing practices) International trade in wild coral reef animals and products impacts reefs primarily through over-fishing and destructive fishing practices. Live fish for both the food trade and marine ornamental trade are often caught with the use of cyanide or other poison, which temporarily stuns the fish for easy collection. Cyanide use is a serious threat to some of the world's richest coral reefs, as the cyanide kills corals and many other coral reef organisms. The lucrative and unregulated international trade in reef fishes drives the use of cyanide. It is estimated that since the 1960's, more than one million kilograms of cyanide has been squirted onto Philippine reefs alone, and the practice has spread throughout East Asia and the Indo-Pacific (Bryant et al., 1998 in (02M2)).

(fishing practices) In some regions, fishermen use dynamite or cyanide poison, which harms reefs. In other areas, governments allow untreated sewage and other wastes to flow directly into the oceans (00V1). Comments: This cuts off sunlight that is essential to reef survival.

(fishing practices) Coral reefs are destroyed by fishermen using dynamite and poisons, damaged by fine mesh nets and boat anchors dropped carelessly on coral heads, excavated for use in cement production and used as road fill, killed off by pollutants pumped into coastal waters by industries, smothered by eroded sediment off the land, and choked by untreated sewage and municipal wastes flushed into coastal waters by urban areas and tourist resorts (97H3).

(fishing practices) Commercial pressures force subsistence fishermen into a destructive cycle of dynamite, poisons and fine mesh nets. According to Daniel Pauly, a fisheries biologist working with ICLARM in Manila, these fishing techniques are now the most common forms used in Southeast Asia, South Asia and East Africa (97H3).

(fishing practices) Cyanide fishing on coral reefs (highly destructive to such reefs) is used to capture live wrasses that go for thousands of dollars in fancy restaurants in Southeast Asia (Ref. 27 of (98W1)).

(fishing practices) Two trends are behind the rise in cyanide fishing: the aquarium trade began to pay big bucks for tropical reef fish, and restaurants in Southeast Asia and China began to specialize in live reef fish (97H3).

(Coral Bleaching) none before 1979. In 1987, 1991 and 1996 mass bleachings were observed in 6 of the 10 major coral provinces of the world. From late 1997 through mid-1998 bleaching was observed in all 10 provinces ((99H4), p. 8). Comments: Coral bleaching is commonly associated with high water temperatures.

(Coral Bleaching) The increasingly widespread phenomenon of "coral bleaching" occurs when corals lose the symbiotic algae which provide them with color and nutrition; corals can survive if the bleaching is brief, but if prolonged, the result is frequently death. A natural occurrence, the phenomenon is becoming more frequent and widespread. Indeed, according to the State Department report, in 1998 "coral reefs around the world appear to have suffered the most extensive and severe bleaching and subsequent mortality in modern record." The extent of the damage was so great that "even under the best of conditions, many of these coral reef ecosystems will need decades to recover" (99A2). The report notes that, the same year, "tropical sea surface temperatures were the highest in modern record, topping off a 50-year trend for some tropical oceans." It appears, the report continues, that "only anthropogenic global warming could have induced such extensive coral bleaching simultaneously throughout the disparate reef regions of the world" (99A2).

(Coral Bleaching) Record high sea temperatures resulted in the destruction of up to 70% of the world's coral reefs. A report issued by the US State Department found global warming and El Nino resulted in coral reefs "suffer[ing]~the most extensive and severe bleaching and mortality in the modern record." The NMFS wants to list staghorn and elkhorn corals for protection under the Endangered Species Act. Both species are suffering from disease and bleaching caused by high sea temperatures (3/5/99 Washington Post).

(ocean warming) A leading marine biologist has predicted that global warming will destroy most of the planet's coral reef's by 2050 and "there is nothing we can do to save them". The world's oceans now warm at 1-2 degrees Celsius every 100 years, the loss of the coral reefs will leave many of the fish and eels that inhabit them "homeless, and many species will die out." (Reuters, 9/7/01).

(ocean warming) Scientists at the 9th International Coral Reef Symposium have warned that more than 25% of the world's coral reefs have already been destroyed by pollution and global warming" with the rest to follow in 20 years "unless urgent measures are taken. Hardest hit are some areas of the Indian Ocean where 90% of coral reefs have been killed by water temperatures that rose by up to 6 degrees during the last El Nino event (AP, 10/23/00). Comments: These statements probably refer to shallow-water coral, not deep-water coral.

(ocean warming) Tropical waters in the Northern Hemisphere are heating at a higher rate than other waters, threatening coral reefs. Scientists from National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association discovered that tropical waters above the equator are heating at 1oF/ decade, 10 times the global rate. Scientists think the increased water temperature is the cause of coral bleaching over the past decade. Coral bleaching would devastate invertebrates and other organisms living in coral reefs (ENN/ Associated Press, (7/29/00)).

A statement by the International Society for Reef Studies (ISRS), consisting of over 750 members in 50 countries, concentrates on a series of epizootics afflicting (coral) reef systems worldwide (99A2).

(over-fishing) The live food fish trade through Hong Kong alone is estimated to have a retail value of about one billion dollars/ year. Some species of fish, selected live from a restaurant tank; can sell for almost $300/ plate. The global retail of marine ornamental fishes and aquarium hobby supplies is estimated at $500 million/ year. In 2001, for example, a pair of rare fish sold for over $5,000 each. Over 1000 different species of coral reef animals are now traded for marine aquaria (02M2).

(over-fishing) In addition to destructive practices, international trade is driving over-fishing and the selected removal of key groups from coral reefs. Major groups targeted for trade are: groupers and wrasses for the live food fish trade; dead fish and invertebrates for food, medicinal products, and ornamentals including sharks, sea cucumbers, sea stars, mollusks and sea horses; live fish, coral and other invertebrates for marine aquaria and the ornamental hobby; and "live rock" or the calcareous base of the reef for marine aquaria (02M2).

(over-fishing) When artisan fishermen over-harvested parrot fish and sea urchins on reefs around the Cook Islands in the South Pacific in the mid-1980s, opportunistic algal growth smothered the coral, killing the polyps. Parrot fish and urchins clean the coral of excess algae (97H3).

(over-fishing) While coral bleaching may be one of the largest threats facing coral reefs, international trade is having significant impacts on even the most remote and pristine reefs. Recent surveys of reefs worldwide found that many species of high commercial value were absent, or present in very low numbers, in almost all the reefs surveyed (Hodgson, 1999, in (02M3)). Results suggest that almost all coral reefs have been affected by over-fishing, and that there may be no pristine reefs left in the world (02M2).

(pollution) Some 25% of the world's coral reefs have been destroyed by pollution and global warming. Most of the remaining reefs could vanish in 20 years, unless immediate measures are taken (00V1).

(pollution) Pesticides, silt and fertilizer-runoff all reduce coral reef health (95W1). The primary destroyer of reefs is sedimentation from logging, farming, mining, dredging, and other coastal activities (Ref. 22 of (93W2)).

(pollution) Coral reefs are often protected from sediments by mangrove forests. Thus the elimination of mangroves also threatens coral reefs (93W2).

(pollution) Eutrophication destroys coral reefs because algae that compete with coral for open spaces on the reef grow faster than coral when fertilized, and because eutrophication keeps sunlight from getting to the coral (93W2).

(coral harvesting) The US was consistently the largest importer of live coral during the 1990s, importing over 80% of the live coral and 95% of the live "rock" or reef base. Ironically, the US prohibits the collection of coral and live rock in its own waters as they are considered essential fish habitats. In addition to coral, the US imports nearly half (8 million) of the total worldwide trade in aquarium fishes (15-20 million/ year). Many of the fish imported for the marine aquarium market in the US are captured with the use of cyanide and other poisons, which kills non-target animals and the coral reef itself. Sustainability concerns will only increase with the growing international trade. The international trade in coral and live rock to supply the aquarium trade has increased at a rate of 12-30%/ year since 1990 (02M2).

(fishing practices) As demand for live fish accelerates in Asia, the price for some reef fish, like groupers and humphead wrasse, has soared to $60/ pound, fuelling an epidemic of cyanide fishing. It is now so widespread that the trade in live reef fish in Southeast Asia is 20,000-25,000 tonnes/ year, worth more than one billion dollars (97H3).

Part [B4] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Africa ~

Some coral islands have been demolished in the pursuit of fish by blasting (93W2).

Off eastern Africa, over-fishing produced an outbreak of rock-boring sea urchins that undermined the structure of corals and reefs (93W2).

Part [B5] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Arabian Sea ~

Some 65% of the Persian Gulf's coral reefs have been destroyed (04H1).

Over-fishing of lobster and sea urchins may be resulting in algal overgrowth (of coral) and the subsequent depression of the valuable abalone fishery in the Arabian Sea (98D2).

(Disease) In the Arabian Gulf, the newly discovered yellow-band disease is affecting up to 75% of the coral colonies in local populations (99A2).

Part [B6] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Australia ~

Australia's Great Barrier Reef is about 92,000 square miles in size (01R2).

The Great Barrier Reefs are among the best off in the world due to the protective status of a 350,000-km2 park (93W2).

Great Barrier Reef Marine Park (established in 1975) covers nearly 238,000 km2 (96H1). (la)

(Fish/ coral interactions) Over-fishing of predatory fish is believed to have caused outbreaks of crown-of-thorns starfish that did massive damage to Australia's Great Barrier Reef (95D1).

Part [B7] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Belize ~

Reefs in Belize are among the world's best-off, due to low population-density (93W2).

Part [B8] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Caribbean ~

Up to 75% of Caribbean coral reefs are in serious decline or under threat (UNEP studies) (96H1).

Removal of most herbivorous reef fish from some Caribbean coral reefs during a natural die-off of algae-eating urchins caused algae to over-grow corals, resulting in large-scale coral mortality (Mercedes Lee, (mlee@audubon.org) 4/14/98 post to (aoc-fishlink@igc.org)).

Part [B9] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Costa Rica ~

Along Costa Rica's Caribbean coast, sediments from local rivers have killed 75% of the coral reefs (by blocking sunlight) (89L1).

Part [B10] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Florida ~

(Coral Protection) On 10/29/99, NOAA officials, upon recommendation by the Caribbean Fishery Management Council, announced the establishment of the Hind Bank Marine Conservation District off the US Virgin Islands. To protect 16 sq. miles of coral reef, fishing, vessel anchoring, and coral harvesting will be banned in this District. On 11/3/99, scientists at the US Coral Reef Task Force meeting approved a resolution calling on the US government to ban fishing from 20% of the 10,540 square miles of US coral reefs by 2020 (99B1). (la)

(Salinity) Declines in reef health (Florida's coral reef system is the third-largest on Earth.) has been attributed to increasing salinity as a result of fresh water diversions for agriculture and urban developments north of the Everglades (95W1).

(Diseased Coral) The number of areas of the 2800 mi2 Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary with diseased coral increased by 276% during the past year (94 of 160 monitoring stations, compared to 25 stations last year). The number of coral species affected by disease increased 211% (Pittsburgh Post Gazette, 11/18/97).

(Fish/ coral interactions) Declines among herbivorous fish in the Florida Keys and Caribbean coral reefs may be leading the declines of coral because herbivorous fish are needed to keep algae growth on coral reefs in check (98D2).

Part [B11] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Southeast Asia ~

Some 38% of the coral reefs off Southeast Asia have been destroyed (04H1).

[B11a] ~ Coral Reefs ~ Southeast Asia ~ Indonesia ~

The Indonesian Institute of Science says 7% of coral reefs surrounding Indonesia's 17,000 islands are in good health; 30% are dead, and the rest are in critical condition (98S1).

A few decades ago, Indonesia was a coral Eden," said the chairman for aquatic biology at the California Academy of Sciences in San Francisco. "Today, it has been utterly destroyed by fishermen using dynamite and cyanide, except for a few reserves and resorts where you literally have armed guards patrolling the reefs" (02D2).

[B11b] ~ Coral Reefs ~ Southeast Asia ~ Vietnam ~

Some 96% of Vietnam's coral reefs are severely threatened ("World Bank Says Vietnam's Environment is Rapidly Deteriorating", Associated Press (9/18/02)).

Part [B12] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Jamaica ~

In northern Jamaica, it is estimated that almost all of the coral reefs are dead or severely degraded from over-fishing and coastal runoff (02M2).

Studies on Jamaica's coral resources over the past two decades charted the nearly complete destruction of Jamaica's coral resources. Coral cover has been reduced from an average of 52% to 3% around the entire island (97H3).

It is probable that global reef-growth is being outpaced by reef degradation (Ref. 1 of (94H4)) of the type seen extensively in Jamaican coral reefs (94H4).

Coral reefs fringe most of Jamaica's north coast along a narrow (less than 1-2 km.) belt, and occur sporadically on the south coast on a greater-than-20 km. shelf. Seagrass beds and mangroves are often closely associated with these reefs, and these provide significant nurseries for commercially important reef fisheries (Ref. 4 of (94H4)).

The effects of over-fishing, hurricane damage and disease have combined to destroy most coral, whose abundance has declined from over 50% (of original) to less than 5% today (94H4). (Damage from hurricanes, normally repaired naturally in a short time, is now permanent due to anthropogenic changes in coral reefs (94H4).) Jamaica's reefs were extensively damaged by the late 1970s from the direct and indirect effects of over-fishing to the extent that two subsequent hurricanes and the die-off of Diadema (a fish that consumes algae) were sufficient to cause a radical shift from coral to algae (94H4). Clearly, current stocks of herbivorous fish are not capable of reducing algae abundance in the absence of Diadema (Refs. 10 and 29 of (94H4)). Other echinoids have not increased in abundance in the absence of Diadema (94H4). On the southern coast the number of motorized canoes doubled from the 1970s to the mid-1980s (Ref. 8 of (94H4)), but the catch remained constant over this 15-year period. The marked changing species composition of the fishery also indicates severe over-fishing (Refs. 6-8 of (94H4)).

Munro (Ref. 7 of (94H4)) showed that, by the late 1960s, fish biomass had been reduced over the past decade by up to 80% on the fringed reefs of Jamaica's north coast, mainly by artisan fish-trapping. By 1973 the number of fishing canoes deploying traps on the north coast was 1800 (3.5 canoes/ km2 of coastal shelf) -2-3 times the sustainable level (Ref. 7 of (94H4)).

Normally, after a hurricane, the regeneration of a healthy coral reef system is facilitated by rapid colonization of larval recruits, but in Jamaica, this crucial recovery mechanism has been hindered by over-fishing which contributes to prolonged macro-algal blooms that cause recruitment failure in coral (94H4). Algae recover fully within a few weeks of a hurricane. Thus future hurricanes are likely to act in ratchet fashion to further depress coral abundance and favor the shift from coral to algae (94H4).

In Jamaica, one of the most detailed studies ever of coral reef decline found that coral cover declined from 52% to 3% across the entire island during a 17-year period ending in the early 1990s (96H1).

Part [B13] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ East Asia ~

[B13a] ~ Coral Reefs ~ East Asia ~ Okinawa ~
Japanese sea urchins and sponges eat Okinawa's reefs faster than they grow (Ref. 36 of (93W2)).

[B13b] ~ Coral Reefs ~ East Asia ~ Taiwan ~

Acid and explosives used by Chinese and Hong Kong fishermen are destroying coral beds in a Taiwan-controlled area of the South China Sea. Up to 90% of the coral has died in some beds of the Pratas island group. Biologists estimate that 50 tons of acid, used to stun fish so that they can be captured live and served freshly killed in restaurants, are sprayed into the water each year. (GREENLines Issue #623, 5/10/98, Defenders of Wildlife, rfeather@defenders.org)

Part [B14] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Philippines ~

By 1981, 70% of coral reefs in the Philippines had been damaged (many beyond recovery) by the cumulative effects of cyanide poisoning, mine tailings, pesticides and erosion sediments (blocking sunlight) (89L1). A sixth of the reefs off the Philippines have been damaged by blasting since 1945 (Ref. 42 of (93W2)). About 5% of coral reefs are in pristine condition. About 30% are largely dead, and 39% have only 25-50% covering of healthy corals (93W2). In a 10-year study the Philippine government estimated that 71% of the nation's reefs were in "poor to fair" condition; 6% were judged excellent (Ref. 11 of (92R1)).

A survey in the early 1980s found that 20% of Philippine coral reefs were still in pristine condition (96H1).

In the Philippines, degraded coral reefs and fish populations have led to an 18% decrease in the amount of protein in the average diet (02M2).

Part [B15] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Singapore ~

All but 5% of Singapore's coral reefs are degraded (Ref. 25 of (94W1)).

Less than 2% of Singapore's reefs are in good shape (Ref. 26 of (93W2)).

Part [B16] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ South America ~

Coral reefs in Morrocoy National Park (Venezuela) turned gray and died four years ago, probably due to toxic wastes dumped by ships.
(See "Poor Protection Allows Destruction of Venezuela's Exotic Wildlife" (12/23/99) AP.

Part [B17] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ South Pacific ~

Some reefs are dying because energy-providing algae that live inside coral cells are dying of disease. A bacterium that began killing reef algae in the Cook Islands of the South Pacific in 1993 has spread more than 5,900 km. Reefs surrounding Fiji (disease-free in 1992) are now 100% infected by the disease (95W1).

Part [B18] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Indian Ocean ~

In Sri Lanka, lime is made by burning coral in kilns. Replacing the infrastructure lost in the tsunami of 12/16/04 is expected to massively increase the demand for lime there (05B1).

Some 45% of the coral reefs off South Asia have been destroyed (04H1).

Up to 90% of Indian Ocean coral reefs have been killed because of rising water temperatures in the Maldives and Seychelles islands in the Indian Ocean (00V1).

Part [B19] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Coral Reefs ~ Oceania ~

In Hawaii at Honaunau, the top ten aquarium fish species have decreased by 59% over the last 20 years, and at Kona the most popular aquarium fish show declines in abundance from 38-57%. Even under ideal conditions, it would take more than a lifetime for some coral reefs to recover (02M2).

Go to Top of this Chapter-Key Habitats - Inventories, Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi7

SECTION (7-C) ~ ESTUARIES and COASTAL WETLANDS ~ [C1]~Value, [C2]~Global, [C3]~US, [C4]~China, [C5]~Europe, [C6]~First World, [C7]~Southeast Asia, [C8]~Middle East, ~

Part [C1] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Value ~

The economic value of estuarine habitat is about $14 billion/ year (in the US??) (92S2).

Estuaries, when healthy, are among the most productive natural systems on earth. Estuaries are also visited and vacationed in by over 180 million Americans annually - about 70% of the US population (1993 figures). Fishing, tourism and recreational boating - which depend on vibrant and productive estuaries - provide more than 28 million jobs for our nation. Commercial and sport fishing alone contribute $111 billion yearly to the nation's economy. (Reference misplaced)

An "out-welling hypothesis," suggests that organic material emanating from estuarine salt marshes finds its way to offshore waters, where it provides nutrients to animals living there. This would make estuaries another kind of nutrient source for ocean life in addition to the upwelling zones off California, Africa and Chile (99C1).

As much as 90% of all fin- and shellfish depend on estuaries for some portion of their life cycle or for wetlands-produced food (84T1), (79P1).

Estuaries have many different types of habitats - vital to many important species of plants, fish, and other wildlife, including 75% of the commercial fish catch and 80-90% of the recreational catch of fish (Reference misplaced).

Coastal wetlands serve as feeding and nursery grounds for 65% of the commercial fish in US waters (84L1). Of the ten fish and shellfish most valuable commercially - shrimp, salmon, tuna, oysters, menhaden, crabs, lobsters, flounder, clams and haddock - only tuna, lobster and haddock are not estuary-dependent (66M1).

Sharks are fundamentally dependent on coastal estuaries and bays - areas that are not under federal jurisdiction - for bearing their young and for nursery grounds. Sharks take several years to reach maturity and produce only a few off-spring (98C2).

Scientific studies have demonstrated a direct correlation between the amount of coastal marsh and shrimp production (84T1), (77T1).

Part [C2] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Global ~

Some 90% of marine life is found in the world's surface and coastal waters (08G1).

In estuaries and coastal waters, 85% of the large whales and nearly 60% of the small ones have disappeared (08G1).

Coastal zones occupy less than 15% of the Earth's land surface, but they accommodate more than 60% of the world's population (99E1) (07A1).

Coastal systems provide many important services to humans such as nutrient cycling, food production, provision of habitat/ refugia, disturbance regulation, natural barriers to erosion, control of water quality, and nursery grounds. The global value of services derived from sea grasses, estuaries and coastal wetlands is estimated to be 10 times greater than that of any terrestrial ecosystems (97C2) (07A1).

Pollution, eutrophication, drainage, conversion to agriculture and aquaculture, changes in sedimentation and hydraulic regimes, changes in sea levels, global warming, invasive species, fishery over-exploitation and disruptive fishing techniques, urban development, shipping, tourism and water sports are generally considered the most serious threats to present-day coastal wetlands (e.g., (93D2), (00W4), (02K2), (05H1) (07A1).

An additional benefit of a healthy salmon population has been recently documented - the ability of salmon to recycle nutrients from the ocean back upstream. A recent study published in the journal Fisheries has found that the carcasses of salmon return large volumes of organic material to the headwaters of watersheds, feeding insects, bears, plants, and baby salmon. But the depletion of salmon habitat has reduced this flux to 5% of the historical biomass, depleting these nutrient- deficient ecosystems of a large source of nutrients. (Continued below)

Historically, salmon management has been based on the maximum harvest that allows enough fish to return and replenish native streams. This calculation ignores the value of the nutrients in the upbound salmon, thereby depleting the headwaters of its natural nutrient fix. "We have essentially starved our freshwater systems,'' said Bob Bilby, a fisheries scientist with the National Marine Fisheries Service in Seattle. (Continued below)

The researchers utilized equipment that identifies the isotopes of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorous, and thus can track the source. Leaves, plants, and grizzly bear bones all showed high levels of nutrients coming from the ocean. Twenty-two different types of animals were observed eating salmon carcasses on Washington's Olympic Peninsula. Jeff Cederholm, a fisheries scientist with the Washington Department of Natural Resources, said that salmon "are a keystone species. All the other wildlife or plant communities have, in some way, some dependency." Young salmon are particularly dependent on the food provided by the carcasses of their elders. Because streams in the Northwest are generally low in nutrients, salmon appear to have evolved to return to their birthplace, providing nutrients to the next generation. The extra food allows the young salmon to grow stronger before their ocean migration, which in turn increases the chance of the fish returning back to the river (Jeff Barnard, "Salmon Recycle Nutrients," AP, 1/5/2000 Watershed Currents - 4(1) March 31/2000 watershed_currents@iatp.org).

Eutrophication (normally caused by pollution) is expected to worsen in 70% of the world's coastal areas over the next two decades (01E2).

In Asia, the cumulative weight of the fish living in its coastal waters (biomass) is estimated to be 8-12% of what it was half a century ago (04V1).

Since the early 20th century, nearly 50% of the world's coastal wetlands have been filled in or severely degraded (Ref. 28 of (99M1)).

During 1989-1998, South Korean developers filled in 400 km2 of coastal wetlands in Kyunggi Province to create urban developments (99M1).

Development has destroyed 50% of all coastal wetlands in the world (Ref. 48 of (94W2)).

Globally, shrimp ponds have consumed 27,000 km2 of coastal ecosystems (Ref. 14 of (97A1)). (la) Comments: shrimp ponds last only a decade or less until they must be abandoned to the presence of various toxic residues

Part [C3] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ United States ~

In the southeastern states (US) where coastal habitat losses are extensive, seafood landings declined 42% during 1982-91 (92S2).

Ongoing coastal wetland losses cost US fisheries an estimated $208 million/ year in reduced catches (92S2).

About 70% of the US fish catch is made up of species that depend on estuaries for at least part of their life cycle (94S1).

Sources of Pollutants in (US) Estuaries (from a chart) (EPA Journal, September-Oct.1990)

Municipal Discharges

52%

Resource Extraction

33%

Storm-Sewers and runoff

27%

Land Disposal of Waste

24%

Agriculture

23%

Construction

12%

Industrial Discharges

11%

Combined Sewers

8%

hydro/Habitat Modification

3%

Silviculture

2%

Top 10 Pollutants in (US) Estuaries (from a chart) (EPA Journal, Sept.-Oct.1990)

Nutrients

49%

Pathogens

47%

Organic enrichment

28%

Oil/grease

24%

Metals

10%

Siltation

8%

Unknown Toxics

6%

Priority Organics

3%

Pesticides

2%

pH

1%

Percentage of US Shellfish beds in which Harvesting is Banned or Limited because of Pollution (91S1), (80M1)
Year - |1966|1971|1974|1980|1985|1990
Percent| 21 | 27 | 28 | 25 | 31 | 37

(US Generally) The National Estuary Program (US) was established in 1987 to direct greater federal attention to these important waters and to develop actions to restore the ecological integrity to these areas. Today, 28 nationally significant estuaries are part of the program. 17 of these have completed and secured EPA approval of their comprehensive estuary plans. (Ted Morton, American Oceans Campaign, 9/10/97, Ted.Morton@radagast.wizard.net).

(U.S. generally) The level of habitat loss in some US estuaries is approaching 80-95%. So fish catches are at their lowest, shellfish beds are closing. As an example, in the Chesapeake Bay over a period of 30 years (1959-1989), oyster harvest fell from 25 million pounds to 1 million pounds because of the loss and degradation of essential habitat (Reference misplaced).

(US Generally) About 40,000 acres of US coastal wetlands that provide habitats for 75% of US commercial fish catches are disappearing each year ("US: Oceans' Woes Growing Deeper" Seattle Times (9/2002)).

(Chesapeake Bay) Chesapeake Bay's oyster catch fell from 20,000 tons/ year in the 1950s to under 3,000 tons/ year in the late 1980s, at least partly as a result of pollution (Ref. 24 of (93W1)).

Scientists have gathered increasing evidence that estuaries like Chesapeake Bay and North Carolina's Pamlico and Albemarle sounds are being degraded by nitrogen from agricultural operations, lawn fertilizers and sewage, the destruction of wetlands for construction projects and other causes. Excess nitrogen can cause microscopic plants to "bloom" explosively in estuarine systems and then rob the water of oxygen when they die and decay (99C1).

About 25% of US estuarine waters that have been tested have elevated levels of toxic substances (EPA Journal, Sept.-Oct.1990).

(Georgia) River swamps in Georgia produce 1,300 lb. of fish/ acre/ year (84T1, 70W1). Marshes along Lake Michigan are spawning grounds for northern pike, yellow perch, carp, small-mouth bass, large-mouth bass, bluegills and bullheads (84T1), (78J1).

(Pacific Northwest) In the Pacific Northwest, coastal wetlands along spawning streams are vital to many salmon species (84T1), (79M1).

(Southeastern US) About 80% of commercially important seafood species along the Southeastern US spend parts of their lives in estuaries, brackish coastal nursery areas that show signs of being degraded by human activities. When salt marsh habitat and production is lost, when estuarine creeks and rivers are anoxic (oxygen depleted), when seagrass beds disappear, those things tell us that the habitat on which these organisms depend is being degraded (99C1).

Two thirds of commercially important fish and shellfish harvested along the Atlantic coast and in the Gulf of Mexico depend on coastal estuaries and their wetlands for food sources, for spawning grounds, and for nurseries for the young. (78H1), (66M1) For the Pacific coast of the US the corresponding figure is almost 50% (78H1), (66M1).

(Gulf of Mexico) The dead zone in the Gulf is as large as it has ever been, at least 8,006 square miles, stretching from the Mississippi River mouth to an area west of Sabine Pass in Texas (01U2).

(Gulf of Mexico) In 2000, a national task force drafting a plan to decrease the size of the "dead zone" in the Gulf of Mexico asked agricultural officials in the Midwest to help reduce by 30% the amount of nitrates flowing into the Mississippi River and its tributaries. The excess nitrogen that the Mississippi River empties into the Gulf causes algae to flourish. When that alga dies and decomposes, the decomposition depletes oxygen in the water and makes it impossible for other organisms to survive. Heavy use of fertilizer is believed to account for 65% of the nitrates that flow into the water. Because of that, the task force was preparing in 2000 to ask states in the Mississippi River basin to try to make the 30% reduction in the amount of nitrogen that ends up in the water (01U2).

(Atlantic Coast) Along the US Atlantic coast, stocks of menhaden (a species that depends of coastal wetlands for nursery habitat and food) have declined by 26% in 10 years, in part due to the loss of coastal wetlands (98M1).

(Louisiana) Louisiana loses 25-35 square miles of coastal wetlands each year. Those wetlands also act as a nursery for the nation's largest fisheries in the continental US (02D3).

(Louisiana) Four million acres (16,000 km2) of ponds, bays and estuaries in Louisiana supply millions of dollars worth of oysters, shrimp and crabs. (82N1) ((84T1) p. 23) During 1956-75, 60% of US commercial fish- and shellfish landings were species that depend on wetlands (84T1), (79P1).

E. P. Odum has computed the monetary value for preserved marshlands and estuaries of the South Atlantic and Gulf Coasts in terms of fishery nurseries, aquaculture potential and wastewater treatment at $82,000/ acre (76U1).

Shrimp and menhaden, which make up 95% of Louisiana's commercial fishery (0.85 million tons/ year) and 25% of the US total commercial fishery, depend on coastal wetlands during part of their life cycle (82N1)? Louisiana's multi-million dollar commercial in-shore shrimp fishery is directly proportional to the area of inter-tidal emergent wetlands ((84T1) p. 37).

Freshwater wetlands in Georgia yield 75 lb. of fish/ acre/ year (Ref. 13 of Ref. (78H1)).

In Connecticut's marshy Niantic River, the scallop harvest is 15,000 bushels/ year, i.e. 300 lb./ acre/ year - exceeding beef yield on excellent grazing land (Ref. 14 of Ref. (78H1)). Comments: 1 bushel = 0.036 m3.

Part [C4] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ China ~

Pollution of bays and estuaries reduces China's marine catch by 210,000 tons/ year (94W2).

Part [C5] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Europe ~

Nowadays, less than 15% of the European coastline is considered in 'good' condition (07A1). Comments: This probably pertains to the condition of the fishery off-shore from the indicated point on the coastline.

Many European coastal habitats have been lost or severely degraded. It is estimated that less than 15% of the European coastline is in 'good' condition (99E1) (07A1).

In the Wadden Sea region (of the Netherlands), about 15,000 km2 of wetland, lagoons, coastal lakes and tidal flats have been embanked, drained and converted into arable land and pasture over the centuries (Figure 4 in Ref. (07A1); see also (92W2) and (97W2)). In the United Kingdom land reclamation (development) has affected at least 85% of the estuaries since Roman times, with losses of inter-tidal areas ranging between 25 and up to more than 80% (91D1); such widespread claim of estuarine land is continuing at rates of 0.2-0.7%/ year (07A1)

In Italy, a survey carried out by World Wildlife Fund (WWF) showed that, in 1996, 42.6% of the entire Italian coast was subject to intensive human occupation (areas completely occupied by built-up centers and infrastructures), 13% of Italy's coast had extensive occupation (free zones occupied only by extensive building and infrastructures) and only 29% was free from buildings and infrastructures (99E2) (07A1).

It is estimated that, in the Baltic Sea and North Sea regions, nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) loads from land and atmosphere have increased by about a factor of 2-4 and 4-8, respectively, since the 1940s (92N1), (01E3), (02K1) (07A1).

In the north Adriatic Sea nutrient load has been increasing since at least 1900 and it markedly intensified after 1930 (95B3), (04S1), with a doubling of nutrient loads in the Po River between 1968 and 1980 (Marchetti et al. 1989). In the Black Sea, concentrations of nitrate have increased by a factor of 5 and phosphate by a factor of 20 from the 1960s to the 1980s (92G1) (07A1).

Despite its relatively small geographic size, Europe has a very long coastline, approximating 325,892 km, including islands (00P2). It comprises the main marine regions of the northeast Atlantic, part of the Arctic, the Baltic Sea, the North Sea, the Mediterranean Sea and the Black Sea (03F1), (06E2). It includes primarily temperate environments as well as some Arctic and subtropical climate environments and covers a variety of geo-morphological features (02E1) (07A1).

According to a 2004 inventory, the total cover of marine/ coastal wetlands in Europe is around 51,910 km2 (04N2) (07A1).

Some estimates suggest that temperate estuaries and coastal areas of Europe may have lost approximately 67% of the wetlands that once existed (06L1) (07A1). (su5) Recent estimates have also suggested that approximately two thirds of all European coastal wetlands that existed at the beginning of the 20th century have been lost (06E2) (07A1).

Denmark, the Netherlands, Germany, Finland, Lithuania, the United Kingdom, Spain, Greece, Italy, France, Poland, Romania and parts of Portugal and Sweden have reported losses of wetland exceeding 50% of original area, with peaks above 80% for some regions (Table 2 of Ref. (07A1).

It has been suggested that, in the Mediterranean Sea, 28,000 km2 (more than 90%) of coastal wetlands have been lost since Roman times (01U5). (su5)

In the United Kingdom, an estimated 913 km2 of estuary area and 550 km2 of salt marshes have been claimed since Roman times for agricultural, urban, harbor and industrial developments (91D1), (04N2) (07A1).

In England and Wales, it is estimated that 15% of salt marshes were lost between the 1940s and the 1970s (04N2) (07A1).

About 15,000 km2 of coastal wetlands have been lost during this long history of progressive embankments (05R1) and the whole Wadden Sea (part of the Netherlands) has been reduced to nearly half of its primordial size (07A1). (Embankments apparently mean dikes.)

It is estimated that there were about 7000 km2 of coastal marshes remaining in Italy at the end of the 19th century, no more than 1920 km2 in 1972, and less than 1000 km2 today (95S1) (07A1).

In the Po (River) delta, 98% of the freshwater marshes and more than 70% of the salt marsh that existed at the beginning of the twentieth century have been claimed (Figure 8 of Ref. (07A1)). The ancient Po delta (until the twelfth century A.D.) covered about 1300 km2, while the modern Po delta covers 730 km2 (07A1).

Between 1990 and 2000 there has been a total net loss of 390 km2 of coastal wetlands around European coastlines, a significant proportion of which was lost as a result of drainage to reclaim land for development and afforestation (06E2) (07A1).

In the United Kingdom it is estimated that at least 88% of estuaries have lost inter-tidal habitats, and about 25% of overall estuarine inter-tidal flats have been removed with peaks of up to 80% in some estuaries such as the Tees (99U4), (05O2).

On the Dutch continental shelf, fisheries are now so intensive harvested that every square meter is trawled, on average, once to twice a year (95L1). This broadly applies to the entire North Sea seabed (97G2) (07A1).

Europe's coastline length (including islands) is 325,892 km (00P2)

Europe's present coastal wetlands cover 51,910 km2. More than 65% of Europe's coastal wetlands area that existed around 1900 has been lost (04N2), (06E2). (su5)

Europe's present sea grasses cover 7290 km2. Historical losses* of Europe's seagrass areas exceed 65% (02D6), (03G1). (su5)

Europe's present wild native oyster reefs are scarce (97M4). Historical losses* of Europe's wild native oyster reefs exceed 90% (97M4). (su5)

* Estimate based on reviewed local to regional sources.

In Italy, around 7000 km2 of coastal marshes were present at the beginning of the 1900s, no more than 1920 km2 in 1972 and fewer than 1000 km2 today (95S1) (07A1).

Losses of coastal wetlands and sea grass meadows exceeding 50% of their original area have been documented for most European countries where long-term data were available (07A1). Peak losses of coastal wetlands and sea grasses exceed 80% in many of Europe's coastal regions (07A1). (su5)

About 20% of the EU coastline is retreating by 0.5 to 2.0 meter/ year, with some retreating 15 meters/ year according to a European Commission study of 2004. Some 55% of Poland's beaches are eroding, 37.8% of Cyprus beaches are eroding. Some 28.6% of Greece's beaches are eroding. Some 25.5% of Belgium's beaches are eroding. Some 23% of Italy's beaches are eroding (Ed Ayres, "Erosion Eating Away Europe's Coast", World Watch (September-Oct. 2004, p.8.).

Some 95% of Italy's original coastal wetlands are gone (Ref. 16, Ch. 5 of (94B3)).

Part [C6] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ First World ~

In industrial countries, over 50% of wetlands have been lost (Ref. 16, Chapter 5 of (94B3)).

Part [C7] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Southeast Asia ~

[C7a] ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Southeast Asia ~ Indonesia ~

Destruction of Indonesia's coastal habitats has eliminated 60-80% of the commercially valuable fish species (Ref. 48 of (94W2)).

Some 46% of Indonesia's peat swamp is believed to have been lost (97M2).

[C7b] ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Southeast Asia ~ Vietnam ~

As much as 98% of Vietnam's peat swamp is believed to have been lost ((97M2), p. 175).

Part [C8] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Estuaries/ Coastal Wetlands ~ Middle East ~

Destruction of nursery areas by land reclamation and coastal pollution is one cause of the decline of shrimp catches in the vicinity of the Persian Gulf and the Arabian Sea (Ref. 16 of (85B1)).

Egypt's Aswan Dam reduced phytoplankton in the Nile Delta by 90%, reducing the sardine catch from 18,000 tons/ year in the early 1960s to 600 tons/ year in 1969 (Ref. 47 of (94W2)).

Go to Top of this Chapter-Key Habitats - Inventories, Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi7

SECTION (7-D) ~ Sargassum and Seagrass ~ [D1]~General, [D2]~Management, [D3]~Human Uses, [D4]~Role in Marine Ecosystems

Part [D1] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Sargassum and Seagrass ~ General ~

Some 58% of the world's seagrass meadows (composed of submerged flowering plants) are currently declining. The rate of loss was less than 1%/year before 1940. Since 1990 the rate of loss has been 7%/ year. This is based on more than 215 studies and 1800 observations dating back to 1879. The rate of loss of sea-grasses is similar to that of coral reefs and tropical rainforests. Sea-grasses have been disappearing at the rate of 110 km2/ year since 1980. The two primary causes are direct impacts from coastal development and dredging activities, and indirect impact of declining water quality (09U1). (Some 45% of the world's population lives on the 5% of the land adjacent to the coast.)

Fish and shellfish rely on sea-grasses for nursery habitat. Sea-grasses export energy in the form of biomass and animals to other ecosystems including marshes and coral reefs. Sea-grasses provide critical habitat for aquatic life, alter water flow, and can help mitigate the impact of nutrient and sediment pollution (09U1).

World aquatic plant production in 2004 reached 13.9 million tonnes (US$6.8 billion). About 10.7 million tonnes of aquatic plants came from China; 1.2 million tonnes came from the Philippines; 0.55 million tonnes came from Republic of Korea, and 0.48 million tonnes came from Japan (07F1).

Seagrasses (rhizomatous, clonal, marine plants) form some of the most valuable and productive coastal ecosystems in the biosphere (97C2). They provide food and habitat for a variety of biota and play a fundamental role in carbon- and nutrient-cycling, water quality control, and sediment dynamics (02D6) (07A1) (su5).

The World Atlas of Sea grasses (03G1) provides the most current and comprehensive compilation of information, documenting some 177,000 km2 of seagrass habitat. The World Atlas of Sea grasses (03G1) suggests a tentative global seagrass area of 500,000 km2 (07A1). (su5)

The World Atlas of Sea grasses (03G1) documents a coverage of sea grasses of 1850 km2 in Scandinavia and the Baltic Sea, 338 km2 in western Europe (United Kingdom, Wadden Sea (Netherlands), Portugal and Atlantic France and Spain), 4152 km2 in western Mediterranean countries (Italy, France and Spain), and 950 km2 in the northwest Black Sea (Figure 9). It has been conjectured that sea-grasses in the Mediterranean cover 25,000 to 45,000 km2 (98P3) (07A1).

Awareness of the severe degradation of sea grass meadows is increasing (e.g., see, among others, the reviews in Refs. (96S1), (00H3), and (02D6)). Reports consistently identify a long-term trend of worldwide seagrass decline, about 70% of which can be probably attributed to direct human-induced disturbance (96S1). Less information is available concerning the degradation caused by indirect impacts (02D6). It has been estimated that a global loss of 12,000 km2 of sea grass meadows occurred during the 1990s alone (96S1), about 7% of the world's known sea-grass area (03G1) (07A1). (su5)

Denmark records of eelgrass distribution date back to 1900 (03B2). In 1900 Denmark's eelgrass covered about 6726 km2 (Figure 10 of Ref. (07A1)); by 1940, 93% of the distribution of eel-grass areas was lost (07A1).

For the French mainland coast, sea grass habitat loss is estimated as 10-15%. This would increase up to 30-40% if the decline in shoot-density is also taken into account (07A1).

There have been clear losses of sea grasses on the Italian coast of the north Adriatic Sea. Geological data have shown that sea grass beds there were probably common before the 1800s and experienced dramatic regressions to virtual extinction in the last two centuries (95B3), (95C1), (97R1) (07A1).

Severe seagrass loss is still in progress in Europe, as is evident along 200 km of the Skagerrak Swedish coast (03B3). Here, 50 of 69 mapped meadows of Zostera marina have shown average declines of 58% between the 1980s and 2000, corresponding to a lost surface of about 10.61 km2 (07A1).

International concern about the conservation of sea-grass beds has led to the banning of trawling on sea-grasses in European Community waters (04T1) (07A1).

Most Mediterranean native oyster beds are in such poor conditions that they are unable to support intensive culture (01B4) (07A1). (su5)

In the 18th and 19th centuries, large offshore oyster grounds in the southern portion of the North Sea and the English Channel produced up to 100 times more than today's 100-200 tonnes (99U4), (05B2) (07A1). (su5)

The main factors that probably threaten native oyster reefs nowadays include illegal fishing, by-catch in trawling targeting other species, poor water quality, pollution, changes to the environment (e.g., habitat loss due to coastal development) and the introduction of non-native competitors, predators and diseases (03J1), (05O2) (07A1).

The total output of the world's seaweed industry amounts to around US$6 billion. More than 8 million tonnes of wet seaweed used annually. Seaweeds are widely used as food but are also an important ingredient for the cosmetics industry. They also serve to produce hydrocolloids (alginate, agar and carrageenan), which are used as thickening and gelling agents. This document highlights the rising importance of seaweed farming and shows how an essential Asian food has become popular in North and South America as well as in Europe. The report will be useful to those who wish to know more about the seaweed industry, about the markets for commercial seaweeds and about the various sources and methods of production. It is written with a minimum of technical language and is designed to assist in making decisions concerning seaweeds and the seaweed industry (Dennis J. McHugh, "A guide to the seaweed industry," http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/006/Y4765E/Y4765E00.HTM, FAO Fisheries Technical Papers, 2003.).

Worldwide loss of sea-grass because of pollution could result in "underwater prairies turning into marine deserts." Among species most affected: prawns and lobsters. Especially hard-hit are the nearly 20,000 square miles of Australian seagrass beds that contain "half the world's estimated 70 species" of sea grasses (Reuters (3/27/00)). Comments: Seagrass beds are prime breeding grounds for many fisheries. (su5)

(Sea Grasses) During 1983-94, more than 900 km2 of sea-grasses were destroyed in temperate areas. One km2 of eel grass generates about $40 million worth of nutrient cycling benefits for the marine food web. So this 900 km2 of lost sea grasses represents an economic loss of about $36 billion (Ref. 31 of (99M1)). (la)

(Sargassum) The South Atlantic Council in December 1998 approved a two-year phase out of sargassum collection off the North Carolina coast. Activists from the Center for Marine Conservation, the Environmental Defense Fund and Reef-Keeper International spoke in favor of banning the harvest of the seaweed, which is used as habitat by 100 species of fish, more than 200 species of invertebrates, by juvenile sea turtles and migratory sea birds. Sargassum circulates from the Sargasso Sea throughout the western Atlantic hundreds of miles offshore. A North Carolina company collects the seaweed to produce agricultural products, including fertilizer and animal dietary supplements. The benefits of these supplements are unclear, said Michelle Duval of EDF. The only company known to take sargassum, it has harvested 10 tons/ year since 1976. The council capped the harvest at 25 tons/ year until 1/1/01, when it will be banned outright (99U2).

(Sea grass) Worldwide loss of sea grass because of pollution could result in "underwater prairies turning into marine deserts". Among species most affected: prawns and lobsters. Especially hard-hit are the 20,000 square miles of Australian sea grass beds that contain "half the world's estimated 70 species" of sea grasses (Reuters (3/27/00)).

(Sea grass) Underwater grasses a key habitat component and indicator of ecological health, reversed recent declines and increased by 7% in Chesapeake Bay. The growth, however, was limited to the mid bay, up 22%, as "acreage declined in the upper and lower bay, down 9%. Total underwater grass acreage increased to 68,125 acres still well below the 600,000 acres that protected shoreline and provided food and shelter for many species around 1900. Much of the grasses were destroyed in the 1960s and 70s when silt from development choked it, while pollution produced algae blooms blocked sunlight vital to the grasses (AP 6/15/00, GREENLines, 6/27/00, Issue #1158, The Endangered Species Coalition).

(Sea grass) In the US, more than 50% of the historical sea grass cover has been lost from Tampa Bay, 76% from the Mississippi sound, and 90% from Galveston Bay due to population growth and water-quality changes (99N2).

(Sea grass) Over-fishing of wrasses and triggerfish off the coast of Haiti, the US Virgin Islands and Hainan China caused an explosion in sea urchins that over-grazed the areas' sea grass beds to the point of obliteration (Mercedes Lee, (mlee@audubon.org) 4/14/98 post to (aoc-fishlink@igc.org)).

Part [D2] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Sargassum and Sea-grass ~ Management of Sargassum ~

The SAFMC has responsibility under the federal Magnuson-Stevens Act for managing fisheries and fish habitats in the South Atlantic Exclusive Economic Zone, from 3 miles out to 200 miles (98D3).

Part [D3] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Sargassum and Seagrass ~ Human Uses of Sargassum ~

In US East Coast waters, one firm (Aqua 10 Laboratories, Carteret County NC) has conducted low-level, variable harvest of sargassum for 20 years. Over that period, a total of 450,000 pounds (wet weight) has been collected. The company makes a variety of products, including agricultural fertilizer additives and swine and poultry feed amendments, and is currently touting the material for treating swine waste (98D3).

Sargassum in the South Atlantic Bight on the US East coast is derived from the Sargasso Sea, located in international waters in the quiet zone between major oceanic current systems, hundreds of miles offshore. Currents entrain sargassum masses, which may then travel inshore, depending on the vagaries of the Gulf Stream and associated warm core rings, ultimately being deposited on US beaches or drifting into the North Atlantic or beyond. Sargassum reproduces principally through fragmentation. Its productivity offshore is limited by low nutrient availability (98D3).

Part [D4] ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Sargassum and Seagrass ~ Role of Sargassum in Marine Ecosystems ~

Underwater grasses a key habitat component and indicator of ecological health, reversed recent declines and increased by 7% in the Chesapeake Bay says (AP 6/15/00). The growth, however, was limited to the mid bay, up 22%, as "acreage declined in the upper and lower bay, down 9%. Total underwater grass acreage increased to 68,125 acres still well below the 600,000 acres that protected shoreline and provided food and shelter for many species around the turn of the century. Much of the grasses were destroyed in the 1960s and 70s when silt from development choked it, while pollution produced algae blooms blocked sunlight vital to the grasses. (GREENLines, Issue #1158 The Endangered Species Coalition (6/27/00))

The floating seaweeds in the genus sargassum form a critically important habitat for a wide array of marine organisms in the Western Atlantic Ocean. Sargassum forms the "weed-lines" so sought after by offshore fishermen. A spectacular array of biota is closely associated with sargassum at some stage of their life history: over 100 species of fish (including billfishes, dolphin, jacks, triggerfish, snappers, and many others) and over 200 species of invertebrates. Juvenile sea turtles (4 species) live in sargassum mats; migratory seabirds depend upon them for forage sites. In the nutrient poor open ocean, sargassum is a unique source of organic matter and of structure, and the linchpin of a complex oceanic ecosystem. Many species are obligatory sargassum residents, in at least some life history stages (98D3).

In late 1998, the SAFMC voted to phase out the allowable 'harvest' of sargassum, allowing the collection of 50,000 pounds "landed weight" until 1/1/01 when all collection will be prohibited (pending NMFS approval of the SAFMC action). The quota was set at a level significantly higher than recent collection levels (98D3).

SECTION (7-E) ~ Key Habitats/ Inventories/ Degradation ~ Freshwater Lakes and Rivers ~

Over 75% of China's 50,000 km of major rivers are unable to support fish (Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health report "Water Crisis Looms as World Population Grows" (8/26/98)). Comments: This refers to the levels of pollution.

Go to Top of this Chapter-Key Habitats - Inventories, Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi7